How to Choose an Online Course: Criteria to Compare

how to choose an online course

Wondering how to choose an online course without wasting time or money? Check accreditation first, then compare technology, instructors and support, and match what is left to your own goals and schedule.

This guide is part of a series on how to learn online effectively, so it focuses on the choice you make before the first lesson.

Item Value
Post-secondary students taking at least some online courses, 2018 More than 35 percent
Institutions with faculty new to online teaching, April 2020 97 percent
Standards in the Quality Matters Higher Education Rubric, Sixth Edition Eight standards
Roles assumed by award-winning online instructors in one study Five roles
Directories for checking institutional accreditation CHEA and the U.S. Department of Education’s OPE

These figures come from UMass Global’s guide to online degree accreditation, written in 2020. Figures and rules can change, so check the source and the provider’s own pages before you rely on them.

Why a checklist beats a gut feeling

Online study is mainstream. According to the UMass Global guide, National Center for Education Statistics data showed that more than 35 percent of post-secondary students were enrolled in at least some online courses in 2018.

With that many options, course pages tend to look alike. A short list of fixed criteria lets you compare them on the same terms instead of reacting to the best marketing.

Start with accreditation

The same guide describes accreditation as an evaluation conducted by a third party that verifies an institution or program meets criteria considered essential for a quality education. It is the quickest way to screen out providers that cannot show any outside review.

The guide also notes, in its 2020 edition, that you must be enrolled at an institutionally or nationally accredited institution to be eligible for federal financial aid under Title IV of the Higher Education Act. If aid is part of your plan, ask the provider about it in writing.

The two main types differ, according to that source:

  • Institutional accreditation: the type the guide suggests looking for as a general rule.
  • National accreditation: typically granted to for-profit institutions offering vocational and trade programs, with standards that usually are not as stringent.

The difference matters if you may switch schools later. The guide says most institutionally accredited institutions will not accept credits earned at a nationally accredited school.

To verify a claim, the guide points to the directories from the Council for Higher Education Accreditation (CHEA) and the U.S. Department of Education’s Office of Postsecondary Education (OPE). Look up the school’s name rather than trusting a badge on its website.

Some fields add a further layer. For nursing, teaching and social work, which require graduates to obtain licensure, the guide says professional accreditation is often preferred, such as review by the Council on Social Work Education’s Commission on Accreditation for a social work program.

Compare technology, instructors and support

Accreditation is not the only test. The guide cites the Quality Matters Higher Education Rubric, Sixth Edition, which outlines eight standards for judging distance programs. Some, such as how easy a course is to navigate, only become clear to current students, so ask enrolled learners if you can.

Technology

At a bare minimum, the guide says every institution should have:

  • a video conferencing system
  • a collaboration platform
  • a course management tool, or a more robust learning management system (LMS)

Ask how discussions happen and whether instructors have ways to reach students one to one. The guide adds that researchers have found live virtual office hours can benefit students.

Instructors

Teaching online is a different skill from teaching in a room. The guide reports a survey of college administrators in which 97 percent of institutions, as of April 2020, employed faculty with no prior online teaching experience for some courses.

It also cites a study of award-winning online instructors who take on five roles:

  1. facilitator
  2. course designer
  3. course manager
  4. subject matter expert
  5. mentor

Use that list as a prompt. Does the course page show who answers questions, who grades work, and who points you to support?

A woman wearing glasses looks at a laptop with a cup of colored pencils nearby.

What should you ask before you enroll?

Enrollment representatives can answer many of these points before you pay anything. Write the answers down so you can compare courses later.

  • Which accrediting body reviews the school, and can I find it in the CHEA or OPE directory?
  • Will the credits transfer if I move to another institution?
  • Which platforms are used for lessons, discussion and file submission?
  • Have the instructors taught online before, and are live office hours offered?
  • What is the refund policy if the course turns out to be a poor fit?

If an answer is vague, treat that as information. A provider that is confident in its course can usually say who teaches it and who reviews it.

Build a simple scorecard

Once you have two or three candidates, put them side by side. A plain table or notebook page is enough.

  1. Write your goal in one sentence, such as a skill you want or a credential you need.
  2. List your fixed limits: budget, weekly hours and start date.
  3. Score each course from low to high on accreditation, technology, instructor experience and support.
  4. Drop any course that fails a must-have, then pick the best of the rest.

Choosing is only half the work. After you enroll, our guides on how to take notes in online lectures and how to finish an online course cover the habits that keep you going.

No checklist can promise results. It only helps you pick a course on evidence rather than on its sales page.

Frequently asked questions

Is every online course accredited?

Show answer

No. Accreditation applies to institutions and programs, and the UMass Global guide describes two main types that differ in rigor. Ask the provider which body reviews it, then confirm in a public directory.

Which accreditation type is better for transfer?

Show answer

The guide says institutional accreditation makes moving credits between schools far easier. Credits from a nationally accredited school are usually not accepted by institutionally accredited ones.

Can I judge an online course before I start?

Show answer

Partly. You can check accreditation, the tools used and the instructors’ background in advance. Ease of navigation often shows only once you are enrolled, so speak to current students if possible.

Are employers wary of online study?

Show answer

The 2020 guide says employers increasingly respect online degrees from appropriately accredited institutions. Many also run education verification checks, so a recognized accreditor helps.